Large Scale Central

Craig's MIK build

The MIK - Annual Build Challenge
#122

Yes, 15 lb black felt is used as an underlayment for asphalt shingles and the same laying dimensions apply. Mineral felt is a 30, 40 or even 90 lb felt that is layered with small gravel on the surface and comes in various colors, and is “hot mopped” or torched on.
See here for example Heavy Duty Green Mineral Shed Roofing Felt- 40kg | Felt Products

I have used the 15 lb underlayment felt to replicate asphalt shingles on some of my building roofs, but over time in the sun the oils have a tendency to dry and the material begins to curl on the edges.
Here is a picture of a roof I did about 3 years ago

DSCN0267
DSCN02671920×1440 343 KB

Just as an after thought here is a picture of my sawmill building roof where I used 30lb mineral felt as a roofing.

SFTC115
SFTC115800×600 141 KB

2 Likes
#123

Now I really feel dumb. Here we are trying to use sand paper and adhesive traction tape to simulate a asphalt roof (whether that be rolled roofing or composite shingles). But Rick goes and actually uses roofing to make roofing. Who would have thunk it. And while I would have said right off that the sand would be too course, that really does not look bad or out of scale.

Thanks Rick

#124

the only problem I have had with it is id you make an overlay, instead of butting the pieces together, you will have to figure out some kind of glue, since the glue on it doesn’t stick well to the grit side. The 2 places I have used it I’m now thinking about using the rolled felt like Rick has used.

#125

Bruce Chandler showed a pretty decent way to deal with that. He butt joined it and then used black E6000 to simulate tar lines.

#126

image
image640×512 68.2 KB

You have another problem Craig. Rooster posted this picture and some of the shingles have been replaced with ones of a different color. I fully expect you to model this. :laughing:

#127

and Devon your water tank has banding issues, remember pointing one finger makes 3 point back at you ! :grin: :sweat_smile: :rofl:

#128

Just my guess but in the picture above it looks like a wood shingle roof with newer shingles installed to patch.

#129

If you all want to know, I made a decision. I just ripped strips into scale 1’ wide strips and laid them length wise. I couldn’t tell a difference after trying to cut a few shingle gaps. It’s not nearly as noticeable when using this thicker stuff.

Ironically, I think the dollhouse crowd is using the same thing and just charging even more.

#130

Devon,

I think he’s got a bigger problem than that! Hollywood and I both think it’s not even the same structure (even though it appears to be).
If Fred was in on this thread he would probably offer to go to the local library for the proper book.

#131

One thing I would not question Craig on is the historical accuracy. I have no doubt in my mind that he not only has researched it himself but has talked with any and all local experts. His a history teacher by trade and a serious enthusiast of local railroad history and a great researcher. So I am willing to say if he says it is then you had better have your ducks in a row if you disagree with him, especially when it involves the history in his back yard.

2 Likes
#132

I haven’t really until now …just asked that’s all nor have I dug into it . Just minor finds here and there.

#133

Well i noticed one also that made me go Hmmm. In the pictures of the ends one has a cargo door and the other does not. But of course that is not to say it was not added at some point. I just know how Craig is and he is pretty dang thorough

#134

Perhaps you should re-read the thread as it used to be suggested but not required anymore.

Just saying

#135

I guess I did miss that part.

#136

Rooster,
I too thought it was a different structure as well. Then I counted the board and battens. They are exactly the same.

#137

Devon,
You’d be right, I’ve researched the heck out the building for a many years. I talked with a local Redmond historian about this building. The end door was likely added during the late 30’s-40’s per a NP request. I haven’t found the AFE ( authorization for expenditure) that discusses this additional door but I’m sure if I dug around long enough I’d find it. :wink:

Like many cities and towns in this area it underwent some massive grading projects/drainage projects. I don’t know the exact date but it was pre 1920. The siding was also moved during this time as well.

1 Like
#138

My money is always on you my friend. I know you are as anal about history as you are model accuracy

#139

Found it. 1906 the depot was moved and siding rearranged. AFE 1906-00477. I can even get you a box location at the archives in Kent, WA. :thinking::stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye:

I need to get back there and have fun getting dusty with old paper.

1 Like
#140

Half the roof done. And yes it looks like some drunk roofers laid the roof. But let’s just call that “preweathering”. It will be interesting to see how long this roof lasts. I didn’t glue anything down, just used the sticky tape on the backside. I’m guessing it will last less than 2 years. This roofing material is definitely getting close to my $30 limit but if that’s the only purchase so far other than a few bottles of cheap craft paint for the building I’ll still be under the $30 limit at the end.

#141

Yaano - If we didn’t keep pointing out our flaws, no one would notice!

I think the rook looks great - as does the entire building.