Large Scale Central

New Water Tower Build.....

Korm Kormsen said:

hmmm…

what timeframe do you use?

if i look at the station house, it looks very old fashioned in comparison to a round water tower.

Hiya Korm…I agree. The station is a narrow gauge one I think and it’s there just for a sense of proportion and won’t end up on the layout, not in the yard anyway, but the water tower I’m modelling was built in 1914, so I’m thinking the technology should be old enough to fit into my general era which is more or less 1900 to the 1950s or something in that ballpark. I probably should be more of a stickler for era.

OK John,

At 7.5" that scales in 1:29 to roughly 18’ diameter. (7.5X2/12=18) I cheat because I am no geometry major and us an online calculator to figure out that the volume of an 9’ radius sphere is 3050 cubic feet which is 23,790 gallons (3050 X 7.48=23,790). Now at 35" that scales out to 85’ to top of tank. At 85’ the pressure at ground level would be a whopping 36.5psi. 25,000 gallons could very easy serve a rail yard, small non water intensive industry, or small rural farm community of maybe 200-300 connections. The pressure is what would be the real world killer.

Realistically that is a small tank and very anemic water pressure. But here is the thing, who cares. Does it look good, yes. I like the overall proportions. I would go with it for sure. No one is going to sit down and do the math. One real world scenario would to put that exact structure on a grassy knoll behind a wall. . .oh wait that is a secret government sniper position. But placing this on a hill even a small one would be a real world solution. Something else to consider and could help give forced perspective is that often water tanks are located away from town based on said hill or its location in relation to the water source. Our 50,000 gallon reservoir was located about 1/2 a mile away from its first connection because that was about half way to the lake that fed it. These are just some ideas of what real world people do to solve the hydraulics problem. To further add to the plausibility of this idea is that often when reservoirs can’t be tall for what ever reason (airport vicinity, or an area that serves multiple elevations where the bottom elevation can’t be over pressurized) then a low tank would be used in conjunction pressure tanks and pumps to boost pressure.

Something like this could be located at the base of a low reservoir in the well building. A line shaft turbine motor/pump combo like this

would be in the well in the ground. The blue is the turbine pump and the grey is the motor. It is a volume pump and would fill the tank. then gravity would feed the above pressure boosting system where small pressure pumps invrease the pressure to a usable pressure and the small tanks help sustain and equalize it.

Now you don’t have to model all this a buidling at the base of the tank could serve as the pump house to hold this stuff. Not sure you really wanted to know all this but its not often I get to show off what I know (http://largescalecentral.com/externals/tinymce/plugins/emoticons/img/smiley-tongue-out.gif). And it could make your tank more than plausible it would make it realistic.