Shawn said:
Tom if you can afford it go with the Shay. Thats the engine I would have gotten if money was not an issue. The Forny runs great but will not do well on big grades. You will also have to add RC to the Forney or the Ruby 5 for it to work well on a layout with minor grades. The larger cyclinders helps only the Ruby 5 and Forney has it. The other Rubies do not from what I was told.
Hi Shawn , Jon, Bruce and Ric,
The Accucraft two and three cylinder Shays look really nice and the reviews point to them as “user friendly.” Here is a nice You Tube video on running the three cylinder model. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qfsJGphS0bY It was a very interesting video and I learned a lot.
I agree the Shay is a very strong puller both as a live steam model and in real life.
It might take some time, but saving up for one of these beauties looks like the way to go.
Doc Tom