Large Scale Central

Zhao Jian, high-speed rail does not make a lot of fiscal sense,

Another one from the “Railroad News by RailNews.net” block on LSC home page.

http://www.supplychaindigital.com/global_logistics/china-high-speed-rail-slows-down

Kevin Scarpati said:
Logistics China high-speed rail slows down Facing value and safety concerns, Chinese high-speed rail endures critical questions moving forward

3 Jun 2011 Kevin Scarpati

A month after testing began on a new freight rail line that will link Europe to China, high-speed rail expansion in the Far East looks like it will be slowing down for awhile.

In a story published by USA Today earlier this week, http://www.usatoday.com/news/world/2011-05-31-china-high-speed-rail-construction_n.htm China may finally be bowing to critics of its high-speed rail system due to value and safety concerns.

China has built or renovated close to 300 stations for bullet trains that are capable of speeds upwards of 300 mph and is committed to doubling its world-leading high-speed rail track length by 2015.

Top speeds for these bullet trains were recently lowered from 216 mph to 186 mph due to safety concerns.

A decrease in speed is only part of the problem facing high-speed rail in China. According to railway economics expert Zhao Jian, high-speed rail does not make a lot of fiscal sense, either.

“High-speed rail costs three times as much as ordinary rail,” Jian told USA Today. “In no country worldwide has high-speed rail ever been profitable.”

So China has hit the proverbial brakes on high-speed rail expansion over the last three months. What’s ironic is that U.S. President Barack Obama thinks the United States needs to spend more on developing a network of high-speed rail lines, asking for $53 billion to make that dream a reality.

Kevin Scarpati said:
In a story published by USA Today earlier this week, China may finally be bowing to critics of its high-speed rail system due to value and safety concerns.
http://www.usatoday.com/news/world/2011-05-31-china-high-speed-rail-construction_n.htm
Calum MacLeod, USA TODAY said:
China enjoys the "cross benefit" of having state-operated passenger and freight networks, so new, dedicated passenger lines free up space for freight trains on existing lines, Scales says. In the United States, freight lines are privately owned.

Also, China’s population density is such that high-speed rail can link up a chain of large urban centers, he says.