Dennis Paulson said:
[i][/i]music or talking is often overlaid the sounds of a working steam loco , sad to say .
I have raised this point with the video makers of many RR videos , and expressed my dislike for all the yak yak yak voice overs of train sounds .
I agree Dennis. A trend I've seen in some of the newer videos on DVD is the ability to turn off the narration and music tracks individually. I picked up a Pentrex video of Cass Scenic this summer and was happily surprised to see this feature. The first time through I listened to the narration to learn some things about the original operations. Later I watched again with only the train sounds and it was great.
If Bill ever releases any of these on DVD it might be possible to have the tracks selectable. For now, these vimeo videos are not commercial products, just having some fun and experimenting. The “commercial” product he’s currently working on is a documentary on the EBT. I believe he has a commitment from PBS to pick it up for air use.
You can see some of the pieces in his short EBT videos on vimeo.
I just love what he’s getting out of his Sony HD camera. If I ever win the lottery