Large Scale Central

Not Large Scale But an Odd American Flyer Varient

Hi Folks;

This crane car was in a collection we recently acquired at the hobby shop, where I work part time. I have never seen this color combination (red body with green boom) before. Most crane cars have a black body with a medium gray boom. Both variations have the medium gray chassis, and both carry the number 644 as the car number. The car does not appear to have been repainted, and the stampings appear original. The only modification to be seen is that hook couplers were replaced with the American Flyer knuckle coupler conversion kit. The store owner has never seen this variant, and one of our staunch American Flyer customers says he has never seen this variant. BUT southwest Virginia was never a hotbed for American Flyer. Lionel and Marx were far more predominant here.

American Flyer was far more common throughout the Atlantic states above the Mason-Dixon line. I wonder whether anyone has ever seen an American Flyer crane car like this before. Hook couplers were used prior to 1953. Knuckle couplers were introduced in the 1953 American Flyer catalog (I have a copy of that catalog in very good condition). The car also predates the production of special Christmas themed trains. Guesses and suggestions anyone?

Cheers, David Meashey

David, I would ask the Train Collectors Association. They know everything tinplate.
https://traincollectors.org/

From a quick search on line that appears to be made in 1950.

There are plenty that pop up on Ebay and other auction sites with the same coloring all dated 1950, some showing as late as 1953.

Page 40/45 in the catalog: https://eliwhitney.org/catalog7/content/american-flyer-trains-1950-page-44

Pete and Vincent;

Thank you for the help. I am not the greatest at using search engines. Sometimes the hardest part is knowing where to start, i.e. how to phrase the question.

Regards, David Meashey