Large Scale Central

My Shay has died.

There is little more to say than that. Ah, well, it had to happen sooner or later, I guess, as it has happened to innumerable large-scale train folks before me. I have often condoled with fellow garden railwayists over the years of the death of their Bachmann two-truck Shay, whose early days of production coincided unhappily with rapidly-disintegrating power truck frames or suddenly toothless gears. I was never smug about the fact that so far, I had escaped either of these fatal blows to what was surely THE definitive model of the late 90’s and early noughties - a frighteningly complex yet mass-produced scale model of an iconic prototype.

A few years back, I even bought a couple of the larger, three-truck variants, by then fitted with the much improved all-metal truck and housing more substantial and far less ephemeral gears.

Alas, today I met my hubris head-on, so to speak, as my Shay, bought in San Diego in 1999 and a faithful performer, gave a couple of desultory clicks, and came to a sudden and final stop.

I won’t say that I was heartbroken - after all, I’d had nineteen years more use and pleasure than some folks had. A far greater blow was the recollection that I had given my set of replacement trucks to a fellow G-Scale Madder so long ago that his name has escaped my fading memory - his need at the time being greater than mine, it seemed.

So now, the search begins for a pair of trucks - and your advice as to where this might be best achieved would be much appreciated. This side of the great Water or the other matters not a jot to me, there is still, after all, a perfectly adequate mail service.

Thanks for reading, and if you can help out, well, thanks for that, too.

I’m in the same boat, just about. My Shay is a first-run, bought when they first came out in 1997, as my first 1:20.3 locomotive. I was doing locomotive maintenance and evaluation last night and saw a couple telltale cracks in the trucks, so its onto the repair shelf for now.

Well, the trucks are just fine, it’s the clicking gears inside that tell me it’s dead - all the wheels roll if I push it along…

I’ve just found a set in Indiana, but they want $223 to ship here…(http://largescalecentral.com/externals/tinymce/plugins/emoticons/img/smiley-surprised.gif) x 100

I’ve seen the metal replacements come up for sale occasionally. I jumped on a NIB pair that were priced too nice to pass on. Unfortunately, the dolt that sold them to me wanted to fit them into a box that was too small and cut off some of the plastic protective packaging. As expected, the shipping service tossed it around a bit and managed to break one of the universal joints in transit (https://www.largescalecentral.com/externals/tinymce/plugins/emoticons/img/smiley-frown.gif)

I posted my dilemma on LSC and I believe it was Rick Marty who came to the rescue with a complete new drive line only to discover that the mounting blocks were also broken. I believe he also sent me new blocks which then resulted in a fastener size mis-match so I put the project on hold until I could devote enough time to get it right. Of course, now that I have the time the replacement blocks have gone missing.

Fortunately, my original trucks have held together with some help from Weldon-16 and a new set of metal gears installed on the axles by Gary Buchannan when I first bought her second hand and broken. Old #5 doesn’t get much run time as of late, but if I ever build the logging switch back that’s in my head, I’ll have a use for her. I also have a nearly new 3 truck that needs conversion to R/C and a NIB Climax that was bought on close-out a year ago, all with a logging spur in mind.

Good luck in your quest. I’ll keep an eye out for them here, in fact I’ll post an ISO on the Facebook swap groups. If seller isn’t willing to ship to YUK, then I’m sure myself, or one of your stateside brethren can forward them to you if they can be located.

I had sent my first run Shay back to Bachmann for repairs at least 2 times. The last time, the new trucks were available, but I don’t believe that they upgraded my Shay to the new trucks. So far their last repair has held.

Good luck with your search.

I just found a pair at a great price in Indiana, but they wanted $223.95 to ship to my yUK address. However, if you live in the US of A, their price of less around $210 would be a no-brainer. They also offered to do a trial pack-up to see how much they could get the shipping down to - helpful folks indeed.

Anyhow, thanks, Jon and all.

Meanwhile, a little-known hobby store here in yUK has found me a pair for £250 plus £12 shipping. and I figure that has to be the best deal around, unless, of course, you live in Indiana.

Please take care, you guys and guyettes.

tac, ig and the working-from-home boys of the Mount Gleep & Salacious RR Company, Inc.

Best of luck tac old boy! (https://largescalecentral.com/externals/tinymce/plugins/emoticons/img/smiley-undecided.gif)

TAC, I posted in Dan’s thread that Jerry Yeramian has 22 tooth delrin replacements.

http://www.largescalecentral.com/forums/topic/29121/bachmann-2-truck-shay-axle-gear-replacement/view/post_id/404364

This site can’t be reached

http’s server IP address could not be found.

  • Try running Windows Network Diagnostics.

DNS_PROBE_FINISHED_NXDOMAIN

http://www.reindeerpass.com/k-27-snow-plow-1-1.aspx,

It shows he has 1 in stock. Disregard the snow plow reference in the link, it’ll take you right to the page with the trucks.

Ah, this is the same company who wanted $223.95 to send them to me. I passed. I’m rich enough to buy stuff from them but too poor to get it from them.

Thanks anyhow, I do appreciate all the assistment I’ve been getting here.

OK, seems that there is also a thread running that covers the fitting of replacement gears…knowing about this might have saved me almost $300, but we’ll never know now.

My replacement trucks arrived at midday today.