Large Scale Central

Movie - "Appaloosa"

Cris and I saw this movie the other day. It’s a Western starring Ed Harris, Viggo Mortenson, Jeremy Irons, Rene Zellwegger, and Lance Henriksen. Harris also produced and directed the movie, and co-wrote the screenplay adaptation. And during the end credits, he sings a song he co-wrote.

We both enjoyed “Appaloosa”. The characters were interesting and the performances were top-notch. It’s about as close as you’re likely to get these days, to an old-fashioned Western; while also being a more realistic portrayal of the Old West.

There is a smattering of coarse language, some frank talk about prostitution; and a brief nude scene (viewed from a distance via telescope). The rating is “R”, but we felt the movie was much less objectionable than many R films. Your mileage may vary.

Best of all, there are some nifty railroad scenes! Unfortunately I missed the name of the railroad in the credits, so I don’t know which one they used.

The last “Western” I saw was “Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid” (With Mr Newman’s passing I just HAD to see it one more time…)

How does it compare? How does it really compare to any of John Ford’s stuff? Or even Eastwood’s spaghetti westerns? ANYBODY can make a “horsesh#t and gunpowder” film. The TRUE test of a western movie is you still want to see it again, and you STILL get into it, even the umpteenth time you come across it on the late, late movie.

Ed Harris was good in “Riders of the Purple Sage” as well. A Zane Grey movie.

Some westerns that I get into every time I watch them are:
Dances with Wolves and Lonesome Dove.

Mik said:
The last "Western" I saw was "Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid" (With Mr Newman's passing I just HAD to see it one more time....)

How does it compare? How does it really compare to any of John Ford’s stuff? Or even Eastwood’s spaghetti westerns? ANYBODY can make a “horsesh#t and gunpowder” film. The TRUE test of a western movie is you still want to see it again, and you STILL get into it, even the umpteenth time you come across it on the late, late movie.


Spaghetti…did someone say spaghetti…is that whole wheat?

Mary Jo Moore said:
Spaghetti…did someone say spaghetti…is that whole wheat?

I think it was something about REAL Indians and Mexican not LOOKING enough like Indians and Mexicans for Hollywood… so they hired Italians…

(http://www.largescalecentral.com/chat/images/3dSmileys/emot171%20www.igizmore.uni.cc.gif)

Thanks for the review Ray. I have been wondering about this movie and have not hear much about it. I thought Ed Harris and Viggo Mortenson had an excellent chemistry (not sure if that’s the right term to use in this case) in “A History of Violence”.

-Brian

The Railroad was the “Reader Railroad”. I could be mistaken but I believe this was also the one used in the re-make of 3:10 to Yuma, what a GREAT flick!

EDIT: did some searching on the web since I posted…seems only the engine came from the “Reader”. The railroad was the Santa Fe Southern Ry. That little 2-6-0 is becoming quite the movie star in it’s own right.

Cool, thanks for the info.

The Reader Railroad was also prominently featured in an early Scorsese flick, “Boxcar Bertha”, starring Barbara Hershey (who is naked quite a bit in this movie) and David Carradine. Not a great movie but it does have lots of good 30’s era train scenes. It pops up every once in awhile on TCM.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boxcar_Bertha

-Brian

Went to go see this movie this weekend, best Western I’ve seen in a veeeery long time, excellent!

I have seen only two “great” westerns since “Unforgiven” this is one, and “The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford” which is a terrific film, but in a very different, quiet way. I thought “3:10 to Yuma” was a good film, but not a great one.

Did anyone also notice that not only was the railroad the same as 3:10, but the WHOLE town set was the same, and the same canyons and other locations were also used in this film? I sure did. Been trying to figure out where they filmed this? According the the Reader RR website, it was NOT ON the Reader RR, as its in Arkansas, but 3:10 and Appalosa were filmed somewhere around Santa Fe NM, so they TRUCKED the steam engine and the cars to the filming location! Same for “There will be Blood”, another great film

http://www.readerrailroad.com/galleries/Film-310-to-Yuma