HI All
I am considering getting into live steam and would like to ask the collective brains trust about traction in the smaller locos.
I’m tossing up between the Accucraft Forney, Plantation or 2cylinder Shay. The first two being within my justifiable TWMBO $Aus price range and the Shay, second hand, being at the extreme top.
My garden logging railway has a few inclines of 1%-5% and Im concerned the smaller 0-4-0 engines will not be able to cope with this and that I should go with the Shay. I spoke to a live steam chap at the recent Brisbane train show and he said he had to level off his entire layout for his Forney to haul 3 wagons.
I have viewed several youtube vids of all the locos and the Accucraft Plantation 0-4-0 with 4 rolling stock in tow seems to have better traction than the Forney with only 2 wagons. They are of course not running on the same tracks and the Forney was being asked to work up a slight incline so its a bit difficult to tell between the two. The Forney seems to slip a lot more than the Plantation in general flat running and that, with superfast unrealistic speeds, has put me off the idea of the Forney.
Is the Plantation slightly heavier producing better traction? In anyone’s experience can it climb slight inclines of ~5%.
As I said prev, the Plantation is within my justifiable price range but I see there is an Accucraft Mich-Cal 2-Cylinder Shay for sale on this forum, which I might be better off spending my money on (or wait for similar if it has already gone). On Youtube vids it seems to have better traction to handle inclines and realistic speed control than the Plantation.
Regarding traction. Is it feasible to fit rubber traction tyres to live steam locos or do they require the wheels to slip to slowly move off?
Thanks for any help and info you can offer to a Live Steam noob.