Hiya Dave - Well, I have a dirty little secret. I started this Garden Railroad thing with four roundy-roundy loops in the backyard. Three stacked in this big space here, and the fourth over on the other side of the path. (Didn’t know any better, I guess…;-))
One small loop still exists; the grandkids use it whenever they visit. Besides this, when, God willing, all my track is finally laid on the latest incarnation of the Littleton and Smallville, the two termini will actually be only a pathway’s width apart.
At that point - here’s the dirty little secret - across the path I will be able to install a lift bridge, already built, believe it or not. The retaining walls for each end of the bridge will be in place, so if any lost stray roundy-roundy should visit, feel confused and dismayed and disoriented, we can drop the bridge into place and let the poor fellow go for it to his heart’s content… Let’s not tell Jon Radder though.
I find I’m at my happiest when I’m making or breaking up a train, or switching a way freight at an industrial spur, so really, making that last connection is not important to me… I operate the L&S as a point to point switching RR., and it would be very difficult for me to go back to roundy-roundies again. I also enjoy bringing a passenger consist into the terminal and preparing it for the return trip.
One can operate point to point on an oval layout, as I’m sure we all realize, and use the oval to add up the mileage, or not…
When I go to shows or open houses, I confess I do find watching all that non-stop tail chasing a tremendous bore, and I suspect it has driven more than one wife to drag her harassed spouse away from shows before he’s seen everything he hoped for. Dare I say “premature evacuation”?
My own taste would be to watch, or participate in, pikes where switching ops are the main course. On the other hand, a show should have something for everyone, and the tail-chaser pikes do a great job of allowing their owners to entertain the troops by getting trains up and running without supervision. At a show, that is without question a great benefit. There’s little doubt in my mind that switching operations are for a very poor spectator sport indeed.
Along with a switching puzzle or two at shows, I always set up a roundy-roundy myself for the little kids to operate. They get to give rides to a bunch of little toy folk and critters I have waiting at the station… It just occured to me that the difference may really be about whether you’re actually operating trains or merely watching them… and I reckon we like to do both, don’t we…