Ken Brunt said:
I certainly agree with you, Brian on going to college. I just don't agree it's a responsibilty of government to fund it or welfare or entitlements for the rich or poor.
My younger brother has three children, my older brother two. All five graduated from US colleges.
Kay and I have four children. All four graduated from Australian universities (in, Oz, a “college” is usually what Americans call a high school).
It would be reasonable to suppose the fees Kay and I shelled out for our children would’ve been about 80% of what my brothers, together, paid for their children’s college tuition. In fact, the figure in US dollars is between 15 and 20 per cent.
The reason for the disparity is that the majority of Australians believe subsidising tertiary education IS a responsibility of government. It certainly isn’t the government’s alone, and our system allows parents who can afford it to pay their share of their children’s costs up front. Alternatively, the children can repay the cost themselves when they start working, or families can mix and match - the parents pay some of the tab up front, the children pick up the rest later.
Having personal experience of both the US and the Australian systems, I prefer the Australian. The funny thing is, you’d probably expect our taxes to be considerably higher to pay for it (and for our health system, which works similarly). In fact, US and Australian tax rates in my bracket are almost identical, and there’s none of the “alternative minimum tax” nonsense many millions of Americans have to deal with.
Even though all our kids are out of school, Kay and I have no problem seeing our taxpayer dollars funding the continued provision of tertiary education. We see an educated young workforce as an investment in Australia’s future, and we’re prepared to pay for it.
We got a call from our son-in-law this morning. He’s just qualified for his MC (multi-combination) licence, which lets him drive anything that’s legal on Australian roads except a motorbike. We’re thrilled for him, and feel a deep sense of satisfaction that the contribution we made to his training costs has helped him get the result he wanted. Australia needs good young truckies as well as good young doctors!