Large Scale Central

4th build challenge voting thread

General Discussion
#21

Dave Taylor said:

OMG This snuck up on me. I went home early from work from the head cold I have, got up this morn and found this voting thread.

I am officially taking my self out of the voting. As I have way to many “Dogs in the Fight” as Kit maker, Prize giver and general “Mik’s Build Challenge” Rah Rah Raher. I appreciate the votes guys as a sign of exceptance within the group of modelers. Thanks for the support.

If you voted for me, pleas re-vote for one of the great builds from this challenge.

Dave

Looks like I need to re-vote too.

Model: John LeForestier-pickle car

Log: John LeForestier-pickle car

Doc Tom

#22

Model Loyet’s tender

build log: John’s pickle car.

Terry

#23

Blog: John Le Forestier

Model: Terry Burr

#24

I cast my vote for Todd Haskins, It is powered and will not be a SHELF QUEEN

#25

This has been one of the toughest contests to date. There are so many excellent builds, so here goes …

Model: Doc Tom

Build log: John Le Forestier (I really liked the format John used. Real easy to file away for future reference - Thanks John)

Bob C.

#26

What a contest! Everyone submited some nice builds and it sure is difficult to pick a winner… Of course many thanks go out to Dave for supplying kits to get many of started as well as the folks that organised this challenge. Dave your building is really awesome. I had a lot of fun designing and building the Speeder and it really stretched my skills. I will have to pat myself on the back since I’m very proud of the way it turned out.

Since I can’t vote for myself… HA ! I loved Miks beat to heck filthy tanker, Ron S and his clean lined somehow friendly looking stock car, Tom G and his beat beyond belief ballast car, John F vat car and Aarons what I thought was going to be a secret confederate submarine, and actually is a fuel tanker.

My Vote.

Model: John Le Forestier and his SEA MONKEY Vat car!

Build Log: I cannot decide since I admired and learned from both,

Tom Grabenstein and Aaron Lotett.

Well done to all.

#27

My vote is for -

Log: Tom Grabenstein

Build: Tom Grabenstein

I was going to vote Dave Taylor for the log - I really enjoyed following his build.

#28

My vote goes to Ron Spencer for both model and log.

#29

Model -John Le Forestier

Build log - Ron Spenser

(Honorable Mention - Victor Smith)

#30

My vote

Model John Le Forestier

Build log John Le Forestier

Mick

#31

Wow this is tough… I have a thousand thoughts on a lll the builds…

So here goes…

Model: Ron Spencers duel level cattle car.

Log: John Le Forester, Set the log bar to a new high…

More thoughts coming after this is over…