Sorry Steve, I missed somehow you have stainless rail… we only tested brass rail. But the black stuff came from the rail, not the wheels.
I too have stainless and run high current. I get the greasy black stuff. I believe it is indeed oxidized metal, whether from the wheels or the rail.
One finding from this testing is that it was found that basically all metals, when oxidized, give a black residue.
So, it’s most likely oxidized rail, but could be wheel plating. And it apparently comes from the arcing that occurs from power pickup. At night, I can see little sparks/arcs between the wheels and rails, no matter how clean they are.
I found the best way to clean SS rail is a Swiffer, using their wet disposable wipes. If you try it, you will be amazed not only how easy and fast it is to do, and the fact that the mop head is the perfect width to follow the rail. The degreaser in their wet wipes works perfectly, will get the rails so clean, you cannot get the black streak on your finger from wiping the rails.
An added benefit is that the cleaner drys a bit slowly, and will actually dislodge and clean your rolling stock wheels. What happens is the rail is so clean, but still has the cleaning solution, the grime transfers from the wheels to the clean track… run a train around, and follow it with the cleaner a few times, you will be amazed.
Greg
p.s. Swiffer found in grocery stores, and don’t buy the off-brand wet pads… they are not nearly as good… and don’t use the dry pads.